Redux Thunk vs Redux Saga
Last updated
Last updated
https://www.eternussolutions.com/2020/12/21/redux-thunk-redux-saga/
Redux is an open-source, cross-platform library for managing the application state
While redux is widely used with React & React Native, its usage is not limited to these technologies
It is an independent tool that can be plugged in with any UI layer or framework such as Angular, Vue, Ember, Flutter or even Vanilla JS
Passing or sharing data from one component to other is a major task and can sometimes be very frustrating. To help us with situations like these, Redux offers immense help. Redux keeps a single store (sometimes called as the ‘Single source of truth’ of all your application state(data) and the components can connect to the redux store and get back the data they want.
Redux follows a unidirectional data flow. Redux has 3 major components: ‘actions’, ‘reducers’ and the ‘store’.
Actions are simple JavaScript objects. It has a ‘type’ property which specifies the type of the action we are performing and optionally, can also have a ‘payload’ property which is used to send some data to our redux store.
A simple action object can be as follows:
Reducers are the functions that determine the changes in application state and return the updated state. They take actions as the argument and update the state inside the store.
Sample reducer will look like this:
Redux middleware = function or a piece of code that sits between action and reducer and can interact with the dispatched action before reaching the reducer function.
A redux middleware can be used for many purposes such as logging (e.g. redux-logger), asynchronous API calls and so on.
Image: Redux Thunk vs Redux Saga
Redux and stuff is fine. What is “Thunk” anyway?
The word “Thunk” may seem vague at first but to put in amazingly simple terms, Thunk is just a function returned from another function.
Let us see an example:
Redux Thunk is a middleware that allows you to call the action creators that return a function(thunk) which takes the store’s dispatch method as the argument and which is afterwards used to dispatch the synchronous action after the API or side effects has been finished.
In the above example, getCartItems() is an action creator which returns a function which in turn takes dispatch method as the argument. After we have received the cartItems from the server, we will dispatch a regular synchronous action using the dispatch method.
I hope this makes sense now.
Now that we have seen what Redux Thunk helps us with, let us now see what Redux Saga offers us.
Redux Saga is also a middleware library that helps us with API calls or side effects. Redux Saga uses an ES6 feature called ‘Generators’ which helps us to write asynchronous code.
Generators are the functions that came with ECMA Script 6. And the amazing part is that the generator functions can be paused in between the execution or even can be exited and later re-entered.
A generator function is represented as: function* functionName() {}
A simple example of generator function can be:
Calling a generator function does not execute it at once; instead, it returns an iterator object. When we call the next() method on iterator object, function body is executed until it sees the next “yield” keyword.
next() method returns an object with a “value” property which has the value that has been returned by yield and a “done” property which stands for whether a function has completed execution or not.
Redux Saga listens to the dispatched actions and triggers an API call or any other side effect you write.
Let us see in an example for how we can call an API endpoint using Redux Saga.
Saga works like a separate thread or a background process that is solely responsible for making your side effects or API calls unlike redux-thunk, which uses callbacks which may lead to situations like ‘callback hell’ in some cases. However, with the async/await system, this problem can be minimized in redux-thunk.
It is completely up to you to choose the right approach for your projects. Personally, I have used both Redux-Thunk and Redux-Saga, and I feel if you are working on a small or a medium scale project, you can choose Redux-Thunk. It will work like a charm. But on the other hand, for bigger projects, Redux-Thunk may sometimes get you in trouble, as it can be hard to scale if your side effect or asynchronous logic increases, whereas in case of Redux-Saga, it comes power packed with some amazing things such as concurrent side effects, cancelling side effects, debouncing and is easy to scale.
To be honest, I love both tools. Choosing one is difficult as both have its advantages and disadvantages.
Less boilerplate code
More boilerplate code
Easy to understand as compared to redux-saga
Difficult to understand as there are multiple concepts to learn like generator functions and redux-saga effects
May be difficult to scale up
Easy to scale as compared to redux-thunk
Action creators may hold too much async logic
Action creators stay pure
May get difficult to test
Comparatively easy to test as all your async logic remains together
Confused? Let us see an example:
Do not Sweat. This is not a Pointer.
